Pella Thiel explained in her talk at the Nordic Permaculture Festival that mainstream science narratives offer little reasoning as to why we should care about the planet with the dominant philosophical narratives suggesting the world is the way it is by pure chance. I can’t argue that the world hasn’t occurred by chance but I do argue that this is a biased way of framing the world that justifies behaviours of modernity. By framing it in this way existing power structures are able to undermine critique against the destruction of the web of life.
I operate on the foundation that the modus operandi of life is to create better conditions for life to happen. This doesn’t explain why life began but it explains what makes space for life to keep happening. There are patterns to life, maybe we can’t call it meaning but we can find meaning in it. It gives a clear reason to care.
Humans are part of nature and have evolved entangled with it as the ecological base for our very existence. We are not any more exceptional in any way than any other facet of the web of life, we are equal within it. We have not earned our right to exist, our existence is not based on merit. We have been afforded our existence by the web of life, by the processes of life creating better conditions for life to happen. We are the life happening. Without the processes of life creating better conditions for life to happen we would not exist. We can’t say that is the telos of our existence in the sense of there being a higher power, but life certainly has the power in of itself to enable itself to happen. This is autopoesis, this is Timothy Morton’s weird loops. Life is the meaning of life.
As a part of this web of life we have two options. To collaborate with the rest of the web of life in creating better conditions for life to happen (regeneration), or to be subsumed into a Freudian death spiral of degeneration. If you wish to live at all then that is reason enough to care.
In a way humans have stayed true to this pattern of creating better conditions for life to happen, but our radius of inclusion has shrunk from all of life to just human life, and then just our individual lives. This is the story of separation fueled by a relatively stable climate, extreme surplus and theistic dogma. This has led to the erosion and systematic conversion of the conditions of life for the whole web of life into the conditions of life for ourselves, or the illusion of those conditions.
The challenge presented to us now is perhaps not so much why should we care but how can we find a path back to caring. How do we find a path back to showing up to the collaboration of creating better conditions of life to happen, with and for the entire web of life. There is no human existence without the web of life.
This requires deep systemic change against deeply entrenched hierarchies and ideologies, its not easy but perhaps as the seeds of destruction sewn by those forces grows roots and loosens the soil, perhaps then the ecologies will create space for that shift to happen.
Good luck.